Arbitration Rulings

Arbitration File(pdf)

Case Number

Articles Cited

Decision

Results 

Arbitrator

Termination – Pet Carrier Theft

SEA-O-0697_20

20

1/7/2021

Denied

Gomez

Covered Work-Scanning,

MCI-R-3818_19

2,5

12/10/2020

Sustained

Barnard

Improper Cargo Screening

ELP-O-0768_20

20

10/21/2020

Denied

Gallagher

Company Email/ Free Speech

LAS-O-4687_19

20

3/6/2020

Denied

McKee

Proper Notification for FF

ATL-R-2019_19

20

2/25/2020

Denied

Barnard

Failure To Complete Job Duty/End Of Shift

DAL-R-3816_19

20

1/20/2020

Denied

Franckiewicz

Error Corrected Before Takeoff

PHX-O-3932_19

20

1/20/2020

Denied

Franckiewicz

Failure To Scan B-Card

DAL-O-1184_19

20

11/11/2019

Upheld In Part

McKee

Tailstand “Abuse”

SAT-R-0797_19

20

10/28/2019

Sustained/Denied

Chapdelaine

Altercation Term

TPA-R-1171_19

20

10/14/2019

Denied

Vaughn

Noose In A Cart

HOU-R-0453_19

20

9/28/2019

Sustained

Bloch

Super User OT

PHX-R-1361_19

7,20

9/26/2019

Denied

Gomez

“Becoming Aware” Timeframes

LIT-O-1286_19

20

9/14/2019

Denied

Frankiewicz

Rep Finger Pointing

PHX-R-1004_19

20

9/14/2019

Sustained

Frankiewicz

Damage Reporting

LAS-P-0192_19

20

8/15/2019

Sustained/Denied

Befort

Dispatch Advised

SAT-O-0228_19

20

7/15/2019

Denied

Chapdelaine

Cargo Screening Term_2

MCI-O-3842_18

20

7/12/2019

Sustained/Denied

Befort

Cargo Screening Term

MCO-O-0049_19

2,20

6/19/2019

Sustained/Denied

Simon

Failure To Follow Provo Policies/Driving

LAX-P-0503_19

20

5/24/2019

Sustained In Part

Franckiewicz

Driving Violations

PHX-R-1527_18

20

10/21/2018

Sustained

Gomez

Instagram Termination

TPA-R-0973_17

20

9/5/2017

Sustained

Voss

Double Time Bypass

HOU-R-2217_16

20

7/21/2017

Sustained

Kelly

Lost And Found Termination

MDW-O-2197_16

20

4/3/2017

Denied

Cipolla

AC Cleaning Time Frames

ALL-5000_16

20

12/16/2016

Sustained

Jennings

“Misboard” LOW

DAL-O-2929_15

20

10/16/2016

Sustained

Neumeier

Med/Arb Radio/800s

MDW-1717_16

17,24

10/8/2016

Sustained/Adjusted

Sands

“Choking” Termination

DAL-P-0754_16

20

9/28/2016

Sustained

Frankiewicz

Plane Cleaning Time Frame

ALL-5001_15

20

8/20/2016

Denied

Neumeier

No “NON/NON” Med/Arb

SEA-O-1083_16

20

8/17/2016

Sustained

Burdette

FaceBook Term Time Frame

BUR-R-0158_16

20, SL 3

8/13/2016

Denied

Neumeier

“Specials” Termination

PHX-O-2935_15

20

7/22/2016

Sustained

Neumeier

SIDA Badge scheduling

AUS-R-0314_16

9,20

7/20/2016

Denied

Hill

Temp/ “Rabble Rouser”

DCA-R-2393_15

16,20

7/14/2016

Sustained

Hill

“Sabotage” Termination

DAL-R-2346_15

20

7/11/2016

Sustained

Neumeier

Ops Job Perfomance Term

PHL-O-0051_16

20

7/2/2016

Sustained

Hill

Missing Rings Termination

DEN-R-0007_16

20

6/16/2016

Sustained in part

Hill

CVD work/video request

DAL-R-1817_15

2,5,6,7,18,20,25

6/1/2016

Sustained

Eisenmenger

Bag Damage/BPC’s

JAX-R-0455_15

20

5/30/2016

Denied

Eisenmenger

Suspension OT

BUR-R-2855-2836_15

20

5/28/2016

Sustained

Hill

MDT shift pickup rate

PHX-R-2985_15

2,7,20,22

5/23/2016

Denied

Hill

Girt Bar Discipline

HOU-P-2232_15

20

5/18/2016

Sustained

Neumeier

Term Letter Time Frame

DCA-O-2925_15

20

5/18/2016

Denied

Hill

Cart moving CVD work

SAN-R-1725_15

2,5

4/27/2016

Denied

Neumeier

Kelly’s Collar Termination

OAK-R-2174_15

20

3/21/2016

Denied

Neumeier

Suspended 6 Med/Arb

Multiple

18,23

3/18/2016

32 Sustained, 9 Denied

Bloch

“Donut Break” Term

BUR-R-1559_15

20

2/22/2016

Sustained

Neumeier

Charter/FBO Covered Work

MHT-R-1816_15

2,5,16,17,20

2/15/2016

Denied

Hill

Immediate Reporting

BDL-R-2581_14

2,20

7/23/2015

Denied

Neumeier

Ops/Freight Cross Training

AUS-O-2274_14

2,5,6,7,8,11,20

6/30/2015

Denied

Neumeier

Training Rate of Pay

LAS-P-2125_14

6,7,8,9,11,20

6/12/2015

Denied

Neumeier

Verbal Altercation Term

LAX-R-2715_14

2,5,20

6/8/2015

Sustained/Denied

Hill

Misboard LOW

BNA-O-2423_14

20

6/3/2015

Denied

Vernon

Christmas Triple Time

SAN-O-0327_14

7,22

6/3/2015

Denied

Vernon

Jetway Bags/Covered Work

DAL-O-2502_14

2,5,20

5/13/2015

Denied

Hill

MDW Temp Assignments

ALL-5004_14

16

4/16/2015

Sustained/Denied

Hill

Aircraft Scrape Termination

ATL-P-1647_14

2,5,17,20

2/13/2015

Sustained

Lemons

Return from Leave Bid

PHX-R-2105_13

2,6,8

1/12/2015

Denied

Vernon

Sleeping Termination

LGA-R-1392_14

20

12/24/2014

Sustained

Neumeier

Mgmt Receipt/Time Frame

SMF-O-0200_14

3,20

12/20/2014

Denied

Neumeier

No Walkaround FLOW

LAX-R-1562_14

2,20

10/30/2014

Sustained

Hill

Provo Truck Damage FLOW

BNA-P-2454_13

20

9/15/2014

Sustained

Vernon

Company Property Term

ELP-P-0570_13

20

10/10/2013

Denied

Neumeier

Fuel Pit Termination

DEN-R-0278_13

20

9/11/2013

Sustained

Vernon

BPC’s

STL-R-2433_12

2,5,20

6/30/2013

Sustained

Lemons

“Time Theft”

DEN-R-1346_12

2,4,20

2/14/2013

Sustained

Frankiewicz

“Job Abandonment”

IND-R-1631_12

2,18,20,23

2/1/2013

Sustained

Lemons

12 Day Rule

SAT-O-1101_12

6,7

1/16/2013

Denied

Neumeier

Article 17

ALL-5002_12

1,2,3,12,13,17

12/26/2012

Neither party lost

Hill

Sick “Abuse”

MDW-R-1325_12

1,2,17,20,23

12/4/2012

Sustained

Vernon

Vacation Accrual/Med Leave

ONT-O-0241_12

2,8,12,14

8/20/2012

Denied

Vernon

Holiday Overtime

OAK-R-2262_11

7,22

6/7/2012

Sustained

Fragnoli

Airtran Integration

6/4/2012

Integrated

Jaffe,…

Plane-Side Scanning 

ALL-5000_11

1,2,3,5,9

4/9/2012

Sustained

Neumeier

Mis-board Discipline

HOU-O-1611_10

5,20

3/3/2011

Sustained

Hill

MDT Bypass/Improper MDT

PDX-R-0489_10

2,6,7,20

10/25/2010

Denied*

Jennings

Known OT Bypass

DEN-O-0480_10

2,7

10/21/2010

Denied

Lemons

Covered work 

ALL-1000_09

2

10/24/2009

Sustained

Barnard

OT Bypass

BDL-O-1699_08

2,7

10/12/2009

Denied

Lemons

Discipline/Time Frame

LAS-R-0028_99

20,23,24

12/2/1999

Sustained 3/4

Allen

Excess of 12 Hours Rate

IND-O-0289_96

6,7,20

8/29/1997

Denied

Abernathy

Ramp Agents/Freight

MCI-R-0222_96

2,5,6,20

4/4/1997

Denied 2/3

Allen

Progressive Discipline

HOU-R-0361_91

23

5/14/1992

Sustained sans back pay

White

Holiday Overtime

ALL/91

7,22

9/11/1991

————

Goodstein