Arbitration Rulings

Updated 03/04/21
Arbitration File(pdf) Case Number Articles Cited Decision Results Arbitrator
Improper Cargo Screening ELP-O-0768_20 8,20 10/21/20 Denied Gallagher
Company Email/ Free Speech LAS-O-4687_19 03/06/20 Denied McKee
Failure To Scan B-Card DAL-O-1184_19 11/11/19 Upheld In Part McKee
Proper Notification for FF ATL-R-2019_19 20 02/25/20 Denied Barnard
Pet Carrier Theft, Synopsis SEA-O-0697_20 2,20 01/07/21 Denied Gomez
Covered Word-Scanning, Synopsis MCI-R-3818_19 2,5 12/10/20 Sustained Barnard
Noose In A Cart HOU-R-0453_19 20 09/28/19 Sustained Bloch
Damage Reporting LAS-P-0192_19 2,20 08/15/19 Sustained/Denied Befort
"Becoming Aware" Timeframes LIT-O-1286_19  20 09/14/19 Denied Frankiewicz
Rep Finger Pointing PHX-R-1004_19 09/14/19 Sustained Frankiewicz
Super User OT PHX-R-1361_19 7,20 09/26/19 Denied Gomez
Driving Violations PHX-R-1527_18 2,9,20 10/21/18 Sustained Gomez
Tailstand "Abuse" SAT-R-0797_19 2,20 10/28/19 Sustained/Denied Chapdelaine
Altercation Term TPA-R-1171_19 2,20 10/14/19 Denied Vaughn
Cargo Screening Term MCO-O-0049_19 2,20 06/19/19 Sustained/Denied Simon
Cargo Screening Term_2 MCI-O-3842_18 2,20 07/12/19 Sustained/Denied Befort
Dispatch Advised SAT-O-0228_19 2,20 07/15/19 Denied Chapdelaine
Charter/FBO Covered Work MHT-R-1816_15 2,5,16,17,20 02/15/16 Denied Hill
Instagram Termination TPA-R-0973_17 20 09/05/17 Sustained Voss
Kincare Overcharge SMF-R-0226_17 13 08/09/17 Sustained Javits
Lost And Found Termination MDW-O-2197_16 2,20 04/03/17 Denied Cipolla
Double Time Bypass HOU-R-2217_16 7,20 07/21/17 Sustained Kelly
Airtran Integration 06/04/12 Integrated Jaffe,…
"Choking" Termination DAL-P-0754_16 2,5,17,20 09/28/16 Sustained Frankiewicz
AC Cleaning Time Frames ALL-5000_16 2,3,5,20 12/16/16 Sustained Jennings
"Misboard" LOW DAL-O-2929_15 20 10/16/16 Sustained Neumeier
Med/Arb Radio/800s MDW-1717_16 17,24 10/08/16 Sustained/Adjusted Sands
Plane Cleaning Time Frame ALL-5001_15 2,5,20 08/20/16 Denied Neumeier
"Donut Break" Term BUR-R-1559_15 20 02/22/16 Sustained Neumeier
FaceBook Term Time Frame BUR-R-0158_16 20, SL 3 08/13/16 Denied Neumeier
SIDA Badge scheduling AUS-R-0314_16 2,9,20  07/20/16 Hill
"Specials" Termination PHX-O-2935_15 20  07/22/16 Sustained Neumeier
No "NON/NON" Med/Arb SEA-O-1083_16 20  08/17/16 Sustained Burdette
Temp/ "Rabble Rouser" DCA-R-2393_15 2,16,20 07/14/16 Sustained Hill
"Sabotage" Termination DAL-R-2346_15 2,20 07/11/16 Sustained Neumeier
Ops Job Perfomance Term PHL-O-0051_16 2,20 07/02/16 Sustained Hill
Kelly's Collar Termination OAK-R-2174_15 2,20 03/21/16 Denied Neumeier
Missing Rings Termination DEN-R-0007_16 20 06/16/16 Sustained in part Hill
CVD work/video request DAL-R-1817_15 2,5,6,7,18,20,25 06/01/16 Sustained Eisenmenger
Cart moving CVD work SAN-R-1725_15 2,5 04/27/16 Denied Neumeier
MDT shift pickup rate PHX-R-2985_15 2,7,20,22 05/23/16 Denied Hill
Girt Bar Discipline HOU-P-2232_15 2,20 05/18/16 Sustained Neumeier
Suspension OT BUR-R-2855-2836_15 2,20 05/28/16 Sustained Hill
Bag Damage/BPC's JAX-R-0455_15 2,20 05/30/16 Denied Eisenmenger
Term Letter Time Frame DCA-O-2925_15 2,20 05/18/16 Denied Hill
Suspended 6 Med/Arb Multiple 18,23 03/18/16 32 Sustained, 9 Denied Bloch
MDW Temp Assignments ALL-5004_14 16 04/16/15 Sustained/Denied Hill
Aircraft Scrape Termination ATL-P-1647_14 2,5,17,20 02/13/15 Sustained Lemons
Ops/Freight Cross Training AUS-O-2274_14 2,5,6,7,8,11,20 06/30/15 Denied Neumeier
Immediate Reporting BDL-R-2581_14 2,20 07/23/15 Denied Neumeier
Misboard LOW BNA-O-2423_14 20 06/03/15 Denied Vernon
Jetway Bags/Covered Work DAL-O-2502_14 2,5,20 05/13/15 Denied Hill
Training Rate of Pay LAS-P-2125_14 6,7,8,9,11,20 06/12/15 Denied Neumeier
Verbal Altercation Term LAX-R-2715_14 2,5,20 06/08/15 Sustained/Denied Hill
No Walkaround FLOW LAX-R-1562_14 2,20 10/30/14 Sustained Hill
Sleeping Termination LGA-R-1392_14 20 12/24/14 Sustained Neumeier
Christmas Triple Time SAN-O-0327_14 7,22 06/03/15 Denied Vernon
Mgmt Receipt/Time Frame SMF-O-0200_14 3,20 12/20/14 Denied Neumeier
Provo Truck Damage FLOW BNA-P-2454_13 20 09/15/14 Sustained Vernon
Fuel Pit Termination DEN-R-0278_13 20 09/11/13 Sustained Vernon
Company Property Term ELP-P-0570_13 20 10/10/13 Denied Neumeier
Return from Leave Bid PHX-R-2105_13 2,6,8 01/12/15 Denied Vernon
"Time Theft" DEN-R-1346_12 2,4,20 02/14/13 Sustained Frankiewicz
Article 17 ALL-5002_12 1,2,3,12,13,17 12/26/12 ———– Hill
"Job Abandonment" IND-R-1631_12 2,18,20,23 02/01/13 Sustained Lemons
Sick "Abuse" MDW-R-1325_12 1,2,17,20,23 12/04/12 Sustained Vernon
Vacation Accrual/Med Leave ONT-O-0241_12 2,8,12,14 08/00/12 Denied Vernon
12 Day Rule SAT-O-1101_12 6,7 01/16/13 Denied Neumeier
BPC's STL-R-2433_12 2,5,20 06/30/13 Sustained Lemons
Plane-Side Scanning ALL-5000_11 1,2,3,5,9 04/09/12 Sustained Neumeier
Holiday Overtime OAK-R-2262_11 7,22 06/07/12 Sustained Fragnoli
Mis-board Discipline HOU-O-1611_10 5,20 03/03/11 Sustained Hill
MDT Bypass/Improper MDT PDX-R-0489_10 2,6,7,20 10/25/10 Denied* Jennings
Known OT Bypass DEN-O-0480_10 2,7 10/21/10 Denied Lemons
Covered work ALL-1000_09 2 10/24/09 Sustained Barnard
OT Bypass BDL-O-1699_08 2,7 10/12/09 Denied Lemons
Discipline/Time Frame LAS-R-0028_99 20,23,24 12/02/99 Sustained 3/4 Allen
Ramp Agents/Freight MCI-R-0222_96 2,5,6,20 04/04/97 Denied 2/3 Allen
Excess of 12 Hours Rate IND-O-0289_96 6,7,20 08/29/97 Denied Abernathy
Progressive Discipline HOU-R-0361_91 23 05/14/92 Sustained sans back pay White
Holiday Overtime ALL/91 7,22 09/11/91 ———— Goodstein